Sexy Indians?

The Mumbai Mirror has reported that Brad Pitt and Johnny Depp as runners-up to the title of Sexiest Man Alive, which in fact was garnered by an India-American. Now I always thought that list was non-hierarchical but then, who reads People Magazine that closely. You always glance through it to see the pretty pictures while waiting for a haircut or an oil change (your car’s, not yours).

Michael Manga, a 37-year-old geology professor of UC Berkeley finds himself in the company of people he is rarely seen with and as he jocularly remarks that probably this news won’t get far on the Berkeley campus since no one reads People there. Sepia Mutiny thinks that such honor was long overdue and I almost thought they were crowing about a desi being included in the list (Sanjay Gupta was featured in 1999 (I think). But nope, they in fact were harping on a brilliant geophysicist being on the list giving hope to millions of academicians who spend their lives in solitude up in the ivory tower secluded from much of the humanity.

However, as I read the column in MM more closely to examine where exactly in India he grew up or was born at, I come upon this paragraph at the very end — “His father, who is of Indian origin, immigrated to Canada from South Africa. Manga was born in Hamilton and raised in Ottawa.” So I guess, even his father is far removed from India and so Manga was hardly an Indian. Sure, his distant roots are Indian but does he consider himself an Indian? Would his children be considered Indian too? Are we too impatient to jump the gun and claim every achiever as our own? Manga might have Indian roots but MM headline — Indian professor is Sexiest Man Alive — is further from the truth on two counts.



  • http://www.sepiamutiny.com Abhi

    Just to clarify, the reason I blogged about him at Sepia Mutiny is because I am also a geologist in the Department of Earth and Space Sciences in the University of California system. Forget the millions. It gives me hope! :)

  • http://alpha-2.blogspot.com alpha

    abhi, it’s Ok..we understand..Patrix is jealous just because he never cud be a Geologist and secondly when someone called him ‘dreamy’, it was his third grade teacher.

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Abhi, there is much truth in what Alpha says. Sour grapes after all! But on the other hand, architects have already been vindicated.

    Alpha, see above link and People will follow soon. As the compounder outside the doctor’s office said, be patients.

  • http://www.suyogdeshpande.net/blog Suyog

    Well, trust Indian media to dig out the remotest Indian connection possible LOL – I was myself surprised with Rediff and other publication going guns abt it. I agree, why is there such a haste to claim Indian part of it! And its not the first time either – another example is Night Shyamalan, who has not visited India in the last 20 years and is as disonnected with India as any other American – yet our media has not gotten over his Indian fixation.

    Suyog

  • m

    while you muse on the madness that is india- have a wonderful new year………auld lang syne is probably most appropriate for you- both for the newyear and for being back in bombay.

  • http://superstarksa.blogspot.com aNTi

    We Indians take perverse glee in adopting a successful person as one of us, but don’t hesitate to go on the defensive and wash our hands off any other person who is even remotely seen as damaging to the concept of “Indian”! Whatever…
    And btw, regarding the media, did you notice the headline on Rediff that trumpets Black as one of Time’s top 10 movies of the year. It turns out that there are two different versions of the list and its only the European list that had Black as No. 5 (i think). The international edition does not feature the movie. And you have the headline and the director talks to the site about how he knew all along that recognition was his for the taking.. whatever.. again…I know I am ranting, but, hey.. I am angst ridden :)