While it may be true that only whiny snobs are still complaining about Avatar’s extravisual shortcomings, it’s worth noting that the Academy’s current membership is comprised primarily of whiny snobs.
[Source:
New York Magazine] Now that Avatar has grossed more than a billion dollars and has received reasonable acclaim for breaking new ground in cinema whatever that means, Oscar buzz has started. But the self-proclaimed ‘King of the World’ couldn’t care less and NY Magazine tells us why it doesn’t stand a chance. I say, if Titanic could win, why not Avatar. I enjoyed the movie but didn’t think it was extraordinary. The 3D was used judiciously and for a change, I did not tear up (due to 3D effects not melodrama). So according to me, that’s a win. But then I don’t vote for the Academy Awards.