FL Babloo

Frank Lloyd Wright (FLW) or FL Babloo, as we in architecture colleges liked to call him, comes readily to mind if we think of a single man who revolutionized the built form. The early 20th century American architect paved the way for modernism in architecture and virtually stripped the embellishments that adorned the buildings of yore. In almost all architecture colleges, students are sharply divided between Wright and Corbu [Le Corbusier of Chandigarh fame] camps with the odd student for the new pioneers like Norman Foster and Santiago Calatrava. The designs they do are clearly a reflection of their inspiration and you can’t hide your loyalty for long. I was a secret member of the FLW camp although mostly my designs reflected the Corbu genre. The Fallingwater, arguably the most famous private residence in the world and the Guggenheim Museum, New York were my all time favorite buildings. I never imagined that I would be able to see both of them in my life.

Alpha totally won me over when she squeezed in a visit to FLW’s home during my brief visit to Chicago. I visited Guggenheim Museum two summers back but sadly couldn’t descend the famed ramp because of renovations. My brother, fully aware of my love for FLW’s work, arranged the trip to my Mecca — Fallingwater. FLW’s design philosophy centered around the open plan concept, the free flow of spaces, incorporating the natural elements of the site, centrality of the hearth in a home, horizontality of lines, and minimum details. Reminds you of Howard Roark from the Fountainhead? Well, Ayn Rand did in fact model the character after FLW – her contemporary and the novel does loosely follow the path of his life.

The beauty of his designs is in the lack of pseudo classical details like the arch, cornices, or domes that you see so abused by the Indian architect Hafeez Contractor. Visit Hiranandani Gardens in Powai, Bombay for a gaudy display of neoclassicism. It sure looks grand and impressive but you are fooled by the exterior arches and domes to find disappointing drab internal spaces. FLW didn’t believe in such deception. You are simply drawn into his creations from the outside and are not disappointed by the interiors. No offense to the people living there but it fails to impress the purist in me. Contrastingly, in FLW’s homes, the world outside looks charmingly similar from within as it did before you entered the house. FLW loved to stretch our imagination and technical capability of his era. Fallingwater is built on a waterfall when his client, Edgar Kaufmann, Sr. asked for a view of the falls. What better view than from the top, right? The house looks dynamically poised over the falls, like a diver waiting to take his dive. He designed a spiral ramp sloping all the way to the ground as a platform for viewing masterpieces when asked to design a museum, throwing all conventions of design astray. The result — a masterpiece much grander than the art it displays. Unfortunately his Mile High Skyscraper [self-explanatory] remains unbuilt to this day, not because of technical or structural problems but rather for the lack of will and ability to believe that this is indeed possible. He paid equal attention to the interior of a structure, not leaving it to minions, whom he thought would spoil the character of the built form. He smartly designed minimalist furniture that receded in the background and let the house hog the limelight. Form follows function — perfectly describes his credo. But he redefined it by fusing form and function and treating it as one simultaneous process. But that did not stop his designer chairs from being worth millions. I remember the tour guide at Chicago telling us that a certain chair was more in worth than the house itself. I found that a little hard to believe but knowing the legacy of FLW, it can be true.

I can literally give you a half-baked architecture lesson on his works but I will refrain from doing that. I am no expert and certainly not an authority qualified to even comment on his work (sense the awe there?). There is a ton of literature on the Internet which does a far better job that I ever can. I am listing some of them below:

I am putting up a photo album from my visits to his three structures. I hope you enjoy them as much I did. The dream house I wrote about, few weeks back was clearly an inspiration from Babloo’s work.



  • http://broodingdude.rediffblogs.com Kiran

    Man! The very thought that Howard Roark was based on a real-life character is mind blowing to me! Thanks for the info, thanks for the beautiful write-up and thanks for the links. I should go through them as soon as I find some time.

  • http://pompy.rediffblogs.com pompy

    i know very little about architecture really. but Mindblowing would best describe the architecture of Falling Water

  • http://patrix.typepad.com Patrix

    Kiran – Its amazing how few people know about this fact. Ayn Rand was actually a close friend of FLW and was greatly influenced by his life and work.

    Pompy – I am glad I found something to blow your mind :) Its definitely worth a visit if you are in Pennsylvania.

  • Passerby

    With ref. to Wright’s designs, i remember only this- “He believed the outside should come in and the inside should go out.” His use of geometrical shapes, esp hexagons, is interesting.

    And Babloo? The great ALW would have been faintly amused at this monicker :)

  • http://patrix.typepad.com Patrix

    Passerby – Rather he believed in the fusion of the inside-outside. Knowing him, he would have rapped us for such insolence :)

  • http://manuscrypts.blogspot.com manuscrypts

    one paper of architecture during my civil engg almost killed me, so i will refrain..hehe

  • http://twilightfairy.rediffblogs.com Twilight Fairy

    aah.. the architect speaketh :)

    BTW google’s showing me an ad for “clocks” in an architecture piece!

  • http://chetan.ckunte.com/ Chetan

    Falling water is a flawed structure. There are limits to building castles in the air and Falling Water is a perfect example. If I were the authority I would have never approved it. It is no wonder that this structure (very beautiful, I add) has taken so much restoran work. I’ve seen pictures of its restoration, and man, it’s an absolute contrast to the beauty of this piece.

  • http://chetan.ckunte.com Chetan

    I add further: water is nature’s most destructive element however beautiful and serene it may appear to be, and constant flowing water–it weathers rocks close to a diamond’s hardness. If I were to design a structure’s foundation to a perennial gravitational flow of water, I rather build it to a dam’s magnitude. Falling water paid and continues to pay consequences of staying with nature’s most destructive force.

  • http://chetan.ckunte.com/ Chetan

    Lovely post, btw. Something to share and something to argue about :)

  • http://hornswoggle.blogspot.com Rash

    very interesting! inspires me to do some instant google search on falling water

  • alpha

    wOw man, you are a true architect! very fascinating. Nice pics too. If I was ever glad of doing anything, it might be the act of taking you there. I’m glad you saw more to the humble, wooden house than we did. I was quite excited about the statue of the Crouching guy outside his home (as seen on the Atlas Shrugged cover)

    But seriously I always wanted to be an Architect..one of the dreams which got kuchlofied along with being a doctor, flower vendor, etc. I also wanted to marry one..that didn’t happen too. Maybe I’ll force it upon my kids..take them to FL Babloo’s house instead of the zoo…to the Guggenheim Museum instead of Disney.

  • http://www.livejournal.com/users/ashweeta Ash

    Interesting. I had no idea that Roarks’s character was fashioned around a real-life person.

    By the way, as a former resident of Hiranandani Gardens Powai, I must agree that the arhitecture was too ornate . It felt extremely surreal; I remember a friend commenting that it felt like Disneyland ! But the apartments were actually quite well designed. Specially when you compare it to ‘normal’ bombay apartments. There was no shortage of space, and the apartments were spaced such that the windows never looked onto neigbouring apartments ( a trademark of Bomaby apartments ! ) We also had beautifully lanscaped lawns and gardens which gave a very open feel. But yeah, building themselves looked really artificial.

    Oh, I have to admit I’d never heard of Fallingwater, but your vivid description has certainly made me curious about the place.

  • Nami

    Fallingwater sounds like a wonderful place! I had no idea about it and it’s just about 3.5 hours from where I live. I guess Fall would be the best season to enjoy the house. The pics looked awesome. Thanks Patrix!

  • http://www.livejournal.com/users/sekhar Aaar

    Nice post… Hope there will be more primers in the pipeline for ignorants like me:-)

  • http://patrix.typepad.com Patrix

    Manuscrypts – Now imagine five years of that paper :) but I admit it was more fun than an engg.college.

    Twilight Fairy – You are ad-sense obsessed these days :) but don’t try figuring out how the ads works, its easier to understand what women want..err..rather what men actually mean.

    Chetan – A true structural Engineer speaketh! LOL my dad, who was also with me when we visted FW had tons of comments too. FLW was an expensive architect with little concern for affordability although his Johnson Wax mushroom columns are a treat for any structural engg, have you seen those? Google it, you will know what I am talking about.

    Rash – You will find better pictures and definitely a better description on the tons of sites out there..check them out! worth your lunch hour.

    Alpha – I tried posting a picture of the croching guy but unfortunately would have busted the true identies of four bloggers :) so a civil engg/pavement designer is what emerges after lotsa dreams are kulchofied :) but heck, I bet you enjoy your work too…not an architect, so what..not everyone is perfect :)

    brainwash your kids and you will soon have them critisizing their own home…no two architects should live under the same roof..so kid architect is ok but kids is not.

    Ash – We already set our bar low when we set the benchmark for a normal Bombay apt…of course a kid doodling can come up with better planning than those shoe boxes. I did study the interiors of Hiranandani and found them to be good but then why did Half-Fees Contractor need all those embellishments on the outside? That irks me. Your friend is right, it is no less than Disneyland but then most people enjoy that.

    Check out some FLW designs, you will know what you have been missing :)

    Nami – Fall season is one of the best times to visit Falling Water…if you have an eye for the beauty in the built form, make that trip.

    Aaar – Thanks! I’ll try to refresh my memory about architecture occassionally.

  • http://phil0s0pher.rediffblogs.com Anwesha

    Really a very informative piece of writing. You mean Ayn Rand, the novelist? Then its a news to me.

  • http://patrix.typepad.com Patrix

    Anwesha – Yup! Shez the one.

  • http://patrix.typepad.com Patrix

    Alpha – I found and posted a picture of your Atlas Shrugged guy without compromising on our identities :P

  • maya

    Nice read. Thanks

  • Seema

    I agree with your view on Hiranandani Gardens… those looks really are deceptive. My dream home will never be a Hiranandani one :)

  • Soleil

    tht Falling Water’s something!

    i was looking for a book about his works a while back…all of them were soo expensive! my uncle’s an architect and he speaks of ‘babloo’ with the same awe…

  • http://patrix.typepad.com Patrix

    Maya – Ur welcome :)

    Seema – glad to know that, so where would your dream home be then?

    Soleil – Archi.books are usually very expensive but you can always browse thru the used books to see if you get a deal.

  • http://raindrops8.blogspot.com/ Raindrops

    hi… love wright too!
    he’s cool! I am an arch. student as well.
    which school do u go to?

  • http://patrix.typepad.com Patrix

    Raindrops – I *was* in arch.school. PiCA, Univ.of Bombay…you may not have heard of it.