Don’t come Bach

Sometime in not-so-distant past, a university conducted an interesting experiment. The researchers covered two plants in separate bell-jars. They piped soothing classical music into one jar and acid rock in the other while holding everything else like atmosphere, humidity, soil content, etc. constant. After few days, the plant getting the classical music flourished and was doing better than before whereas the one getting the rock treatment wilted and died. I bet those researchers had more than their share of parents of teenagers as they carried a seemingly valuable lesson home. The dinner conversation surely must have been interesting. While not knowing the veracity of this experiment, an urban legend was soon born that listening to classical music enhanced your concentration and made your mind sharper hence creating a conducive environment for academic pursuits.

About a year back as I was approaching an important exam, I decided to conduct this experiment on myself. Silence makes me go mad and I need a little hustle-bustle around me to focus better. Usually I have my ears covered with earphones piping a varied assortment of music into my brain to drown out the distracting background noise (visual distractions are easier to avoid). I bought a 3-CD pack of Sunday Morning Classics featuring pieces by almost all notable masters — Chopin, Beethoven, Mozart, Strauss, and the entire gang. Unfortunately, the experiment didn’t work and I found myself falling asleep instead of focusing better. Of course, the experiment was unscientific by any standards. But it proved the urban legend-esque quality of pitting classical music against rock. One of my classmates just couldn’t get his work done without the accompaniment of Led Zeppelin’s hard metal and his end product was always good although a woefully late.

Classical music aficionados have always differed from rock enthusiasts and have been different as chalk and cheese. Recently people who have understood this distinct separation put it to good use. Kevin Drum at Washington Monthly mentions an innovative strategy employed by Co-op, a chain of grocery stores.

Co-op, a chain of grocery stores, is experimenting with playing classical music outside its shops, to stop youths from hanging around and intimidating customers. It seems to work well. Staff have a remote control and “can turn the music on if there’s a situation developing and they need to disperse people”, says Steve Broughton of Co-op.

Teenagers make it a point to run away from classical music and even if they like it, not one would be caught listening to Bach. Over the years, some of them develop a “fine taste” for music and start appreciating the nuances of classical music. But like Kevin, I too believe that this remedy is short-lived and teenagers will develop same kind of immunity as mosquitoes develop for Baygon. Foreign Dispatches also scoffs at the “miraculous powers that the music of Mozart and Beethoven might possess”. But as a temporary respite, driving away rowdy teenagers is a classic idea; no pun intended. Now I understand why Atlanta Bread Company plays those dull pieces on Friday evenings when school kids hang out at the local theater plaza.


Related Posts

  1. Please Don’t Attack Us
  2. Don’t Block the Blog
  3. Structure Behind Music

  • http://foreigndispatches.typepad.com/ Abiola Lapite

    Er, why the trackback when you don’t even bother to mention my site?

  • Passerby

    Western classical doesn’t work for me simply coz i can’t figure out the tune most times. Rock’s good when the morale is low and i have to motivate myself to meet a deadline. But hey, Richard Clayderman’s perfect to listen to while working. Ever tried instrumental versions of popular songs?

  • http://absolutelee.rediffblogs.com Leela

    Classical music rocks!

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Abiola – Oops! You were mentioned in my first draft. Anyways, since you too wrote on the topic, the trackback doesn’t hurt. Anyways, edited the post to include mentioning your take too.

    Passerby – Yup! the songs sound different and you hear pieces of music that you neglect. Ever heard of Anand Shankar’s music?

    Leela – You will always walk the thin line of pleasing both sides of the warring parties, right?

  • http://www.thescian.com Selva

    :-). Where did you get the Plant experiment… It’s a myth. See [ http://www.science.ca/askascientist/viewquestion.php?qID=281 ] A few enterprising folks have done some experiment. But nothing that can be called a scientific experiment (controlled, repeatable, falsifiable).

    There is a connection I know of between Plants and Music . Japanese have managed to make Plants into Speakers. See [ http://science.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=04/09/15/030244&tid=141&tid=126&tid=14 ]

    The effect of classical music on teenagers! That’s true – be it western or Indian. It is mostly an acquired response due to peer pressure (my-unlearned-opinion warning). Time cures it usually. :-)

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Selva – I wasn’t too sure of its veracity and I had my doubts. The plants-speakers sure is interesting but it is like those cell phone towers that look like pine trees on the interstates…just a good camouflage technique.

  • http://sporadicthoughts.rediffblogs.com/ ADI

    Led zepp is way way better than Back/Mozart/Beethoven. Led zepp rocks

  • alpha

    You and music?! :O I have seen it all. Classical music to certain youths has the same effect football has on me.

  • http://paythals.blogspot.com TOL

    Reg ur expt, I guess its more in tune with each persons interest. I for one really believe that Rahman helped me pass my prelims;)

  • http://foolsparadise.blog-city.com Queer

    As far as I am able to get the necessary info into my brain..it does not matter where I am. I like classical music..western and indian (C&H). Of late, started with ghazals too;)

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Adi – I guess Leela will have to discipline you with some of her Beethoven magic.

    Alpha – Don’t go by my singing abilities. I definitely know more about an omlette than a hen does.

    TOL – Rahman deserves thanks for helping us get through lot of shit.

    Queer – you like classical stuff? Guess you are over the hill then :)

  • http://absolutelee.rediffblogs.com Leela

    No thin line at all Patrix. It’s only classical music, as far as I’m concerned. ‘Over the hill’, eh? Get ready to meet your maker.

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Leela – Tsk Tsk..so no tapori numbers for you, I guess? My Maker…lives in Cuffe Parade kya? ok ok..bad joke :)

  • Parmanu

    Fell asleep?! Try Tchaikovsky. He’ll keep you awake, but I can’t guarantee that you’ll focus on your books better.

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Parmanu – I will. I do like some classical stuff but helping me focus better is a thing that it can’t do any better than dhinchak music.

  • http://www.theovergrownpath.blogspot.com Pliable

    Interesting post – classical music definitely does have a role as an enabler in both education and therapy. There is some interesting work going on by people like Prof Paul Robertson and the cellist Ruth Phillips.
    More about this, and links to their web sites and more at http://www.theovergrownpath.blogspot.com
    I’m interested in developing music as a stimulant for writing and communication in adult literacy programmes, contact me via my blog please.