Bollywood Censorship

We take for granted censorship in Bollywood movies and aren’t fazed when we hear of harried directors made to run from pillar to post regarding some ‘objectionable’ scenes in their movies. Even when decisions like the recent one to ban smoking from movies or else be accompanied with a health warning has lead to outrage among bloggers, I have not come across a single editorial in the mainstream media (Aamir ranted about the decision a little but ended up confusing everyone by granting the government the right to ban smoking altogether). I have often wondered why anyone hasn’t sought legal assistance against the very idea of censorship. I was baffled when I read that a high-court ruling in 1970 has effectively affirmed the role of the government as a film censor. However, they also make ambiguous statements that still cause director-censor board wrangling:

“It is not elements of rape, leprosy, sexual immorality which should attract the censor’s scissors but how the theme is handled by the producer.”

No wonder one person’s ‘context’ draws another’s gasp of shock. Frankly, we are better off without the censor. Let the public decide. If it is soft-pron movies they want, they will get it. Relentless marauders haven’t damaged our ‘rich culture and heritage’, what makes the government think that a stupid movie can?

Update: Sruthijith over at Indian Express writes against state-controlled ‘culture protection’.


Related Posts

  1. No quality left in Bollywood?
  2. Best of Bollywood Blogs
  3. The Five Point Someone Movie
  • Pingback: varnam

  • http://www.semanticoverload.blogspot.com semantic overload

    I dont think censorship is needed but I think rating movies woudl do good. You can produce any kind of movie you want.. but you will have to accept the rating you get… be it U, A, X, AA, PG-13 whatever.. That way the director and producer can have all the freedom they want.

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Semantic – Rating movies is an idea proposed everytime but rarely implemented.

  • :-)

    Running scrolls whenever some one lights up a cigerette is –needless to say– plain stupid. Behind all the cultural hoopla Indian movies are plain vulgar and extremely violent in nature.

    Hollywood is atleast honest in its greed and intensity.

    I watch a lot of English and local (Hindi and Telugu) movies. On any day I would hesitate to watch a Telugu or Hindi film with my family.

    Its just another leftover of west. (West so far had been harsh on smoking for toatlly different sensitive, socio political and economic reasons)

    Bah, I guess I am confused too. To conclude, I dont like this idea.

  • http://imsri.blogspot.com Ramana

    Hey, that’s so true, patrix..we consider our audience kids who need to be told what to watch and what not to, and that’s the trouble.

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Smiley – Long time, eh? anyway, I agree that Bollywood tends to think that violence and crude humor is acceptable but smoking is not.

    Ramana – Yup, we ought to stop preaching to our kids and I am not just talking about what movies should they watch.

  • http://www.parablog.com/ Parag

    Patrix: I hope you’ll remember your statement and make use of it in a few years when you have your own kids. I really would like to see how you hold up to it… :-)
    we ought to stop preaching to our kids and I am not just talking about what movies should they watch.

    I am very much against bans of any kind. I think it is parents’ responsibility to protect their children. Let me give you a simple example. I find myself scrambling to keep copies of Sprots Illustrated away from my daughter, so that she doesn’t see the cigarette and liquor ads in it. I think I am just going to cancel the subscription.