To Revive or Not?

The question that seems to be on everyone’s mind – should we rebuild New Orleans or not? Interestingly, there has been quite some debate going on as the city resurfaces from the sickening flood. The city may be uninhabitable for at least six months and the people that have left may not return. It is thus important to ask, what parts of New Orleans should we preserve. It is a city along with San Francisco that is home to "the greatest collection of 18th-, 19th-  and early-20th-century residential architecture in the United StatesYou’re talking about miles and miles of historic properties.", says Reed Kroloff, Dean of School of Architecture, Tulane University.

On the other hand, there are some people who do not favor forced preservation of a city built on the edge (literally). "Any city that only tries to preserve itself is already dead, the great tragedy would be to embalm New Orleans by simply rebuilding it the way it was", says Mark Wigley, dean of Columbia University’s Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation [source: NY Times]. Others fear that it may just end up like Disneyland in its attempt to preserve the architecture. But one thing is sure, the larger swath of New Orleans where tourists don’t go might not be revived at all. As mentioned earlier, I was in New Orleans a month before the hurricane made landfall. The pictures I took do show to some extent the unique architecture that begs to be preserved. On a good note, I recently learnt that the French Quarter (the part I visited and photographed) was largely untouched and may be habitable soon.



  • http://alpha-2.blogspot.com alpha

    Well, I am off for doing just that.

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Alpha, Great! this could be really insightful for all of us. Please keep us posted either through your blog or emails.

  • http://curiousgawker.blogspot.com/ gawker

    The matter is debatable. But I do know this: I will not tolerate conservatives telling me they do not want to put taxpayers money into rebuilding it, saying “I do think taxpayers should be asked and politicians who take a position one way or the other should expect to be held accountable.” and “I’d like to hear the price tag first.”. No one asked my opinion as a taxpayer before going to Iraq, if I wanted to spend my tax money on bombing the hell out of the people there, and no one notified me of the price tag either. At least, not the REAL price tag.

  • http://ipatrix.com Patrix

    Gawker, you have a point there. No one can really ascribe public opinion to this issue because everyone has a different stake in the issue.

  • Pingback: The Renegade of Junk